Why don’t Contemporary Veterans join RSAs?

Hayden Ricketts (retired 26 year veteran from Army. Served in UNTSO, 2004 Boxing Day Tsunami, Timor Leste, and the MFO) Co-director Mission Homefront. Speech to RNZRSA National Council, 21 November 2026.

 

Ka tangi te titi

Ka tangi te kāka

Ka tangi hoki āhau

Tēhei, mauri ora.

Tēnā koutou, e nga rangitira ma

Tēnā koutou nga whānau.

It is a privilege to speak at the National Council about a question that goes to the heart of the future: why do so many younger veterans not join, or engage with, the RSA?

This time slot is for 45 minutes, you will be pleased to know that I don’t intend to use it all, for I fear that some of you will need a pee stop halfway through.

My plan today is to tell you a bit about me, share my experiences and what people have told me, say thank you, and then sit down.

Throughout, I will use the term ‘contemporary veteran’. To be clear, I intend this term to mean those veterans that served since 1995, from Bosnia onwards. As this is what I consider to be the start of the decline from the ‘heydays’ of the 80’s and early 90’s, this is the period after  ‘way back when’, when our military had things like postings to Singapore, a 4 frigate Navy, real tanks, and a fighter jet strike wing. The military back then also had things like the government superannuation scheme, and many other conditions of service that have long since been removed.

My name is Hayden, and I grew up on a sheep and beef farm just over the Cook Strait near a little town called Blenheim. My great grandfather went ashore at Gallipoli, and survived the Somme, and Belgium and returned home in 1919. Both my grandfathers served in WW2, one as an ammunition truck driver in the ASC, and the other in the 33rd Anti tank sqn. My father was conscripted into National Service in the Artillery (poor bugger) in 1971. The Army it would seem, is in my blood.

In 1998 I turned 19, three weeks later I joined the Army. As I travelled North to Waiouru Camp to begin basic training, Wellington was the furthest North I had ever been. Every kilometre that bus travelled was breaking new ground on my new adventure. When I retired in 2024 after 26 years in the RNZIR, I had served in 5 missions overseas, visited 42 different countries, got married, had two kids, got divorced. Along the way I made friends, and found comrades in many of the amazing people in the NZDF. Some I called some brother, or sister.  And like many of you, I buried some of New Zealand’s finest people, killed on operations, or accidents here in NZ, died from cancer, or died by their own hand.

The best time I had in the military was training young people, and watching them succeed and to go on to bigger and better things. I still get a kick out of catching up with many of them, and reminding them that I extremely proud to have some small chip in that persons game.

The worst time I spent in the military was feeling that I was doing the impossible, for the ungrateful, or being led by the indifferent. That while I was furiously trying to do my best to live up to the values of the Army, there were others out there for whom those values of courage, commitment, comradeship, and integrity were less important.

I often say that the only person who knows the value of a medal, is the person who’s chest it is sitting on. The medal on my chest, that means the most to me is the SSM for the 2004 boxing day Tsunami. The day after boxing day, I got a phone call from the Adjutant, and got on a Hercules 19 hours later. 250,000 people were killed in that event, 150,000 of them in Indonesia, most of them in Banda Aceh. 150,000 is the population of Tauranga, or everyone living in the Hutt Valley. I remember the complete devastation, sections of city practically wiped from the earth.  Mud everywhere, ships inland in places where no ships should be, a fishing fleet of score of boats, smashed against the bridge, turned to matchsticks, along with the people inside them. I remember nearly everything from that month, including the faces. Most of all I remember the smell, you can imagine the scenes. Just know that rotting meat brings back all those memories, and sends me straight back there. I was 24.

After speaking to a good friend who helped me navigate the process, about 7 months ago I sent my forms into Veterans affairs. After living with it for 22 years, about 7 weeks ago I was diagnosed with PTSD, mostly related to my time in Banda Aceh.

About here, I want to say something very clearly: younger veterans have not stopped caring about service, remembrance, mateship, or the welfare of those who have served. Many have not stopped caring about the RSA either. But what many have concluded is that the RSA, as they experience it, is not built for them.

So lets start with who is a veteran? For many people, veterans are people who fought in world wars, korea, or Vietnam. Others extend this to those that served in contemporary operations. UN Missions in Bosnia, Africa, Middle East, and Asia, Timor Leste, Bouganville, Solomon Islands, Afghanistan. Others recognise Iraq, and the training missions supporting Ukraine. Most people can agree that those people are veterans. Few people think of those that supported international or domestic disaster relief or humanitarian support operations. Banda Aceh, Cyclones or Tsunami’s in Fiji, Tonga, Samoa or Vanuatu. Christchurch or Kaikoura Earthquake. Cyclone Gabrielle. Even fewer still recognise those that may not have served overseas, but still served. They attested, were trained, trained others, did what the country needed of them in over the many years when there just were no few overseas operations, except may be for officers. Contemporary veterans crewed the managed isolation facility’s, or those that just ‘held the line’, kept the standards, long enough for others them come and to take their place. We must remember that not all veterans wear medals.

In that regard I think of those that were on basic training in Waiouru in 2003 when Gedye Morehu died of meningitis, 24 hours after reporting sick. I think of those that were on the lake the day that Micheal Ross drowned in Lake Moawhango in 2012. And I think of those countless others that were harmed by their service in NZ through the accidents and incidents that are inherent in the dangerous work of training to bring military effect to bear in the name of our country. They all served. And we should remember, that all are veterans.

Not long after I left the military, I saw in the paper a story about a woman named Erin Speedy and a letter she’d written to the Minister of Defence. As a retired journalist, she has also emailed the letter to her mates in every news agency in the country. The letter was intended to draw attention to the shocking state of military housing. Erin went viral with the Kaupapa, and ended up on TV with the associate Minister of Defence Chris Penk explaining how bad her old, cold, mouldy, house in Waiouru really was. Particularly as her family was just getting over another bout of illness during the Winter. A few phone calls later, some emails and many cups of coffee, we established Mission Homefront as a way to try to educate, and raise awareness of the general public and politicians on the plight of the current serving people. Mission Homefront advocates on behalf of current serving people for better, pay, housing, conditions of service, welfare provisions and recognition. As I saw this as the role and remit of the RSA, the returned and services association, I engaged with the then CE’s of the National Body (there have been three in my time in Mission Homefront) and was told that we have enough to do in stopping the RSA from imploding. The for us in the ‘national space’ to do this was fair game, and to ‘go for it’. So that we did.

Which brings me back to veterans.

By my definition, all of the current serving soldiers, sailors and aviators are veterans too. The veterans of, Bosnia, Bougainville, Timor Leste, the Solomons, Iraq, Afghanistan, the Middle East, support to Ukraine, and contemporary peacekeeping operations in Africa and asia, are not a future problem for the RSA. They are the present. They are now among the largest groups of former service personnel in New Zealand, and they bring experience, skills, along with children, and families, they have needs and expectations that must be reflected in the RSA’s work if it is to be successful.

This modern, contemporary veteran has a service history that is unique to them. Like your history is unique to you. These veteran’s service has been defined by the ‘forever war’ of Afghanistan. They live with the shame of that defeat at the hands of the Taliban. A feeling that I know some of you can empathise. They live with the thought that all that work, all that sweat, and the time in their lives they will never get back, counted for nothing. They live with the insidious and nightmarish thought, that the lives of 10 New Zealanders killed in Afghanistan, also meant nothing. This generation lives with the shame of the sinking of the Manawanui, and the shame of the CDF resigning in disgrace in a shadow of lies. And although they are not responsible for any of those things, contemporary veterans feel the weight of those events as a consequence none-the-less.

We should remember that contemporary veterans are a product of the society that created them. Veterans are Men. Veterans are women. There are veterans that are somewhere in-between. Veterans are maori, chinese, indian, and pacific islanders. English may not be their first language. They all deserve a place in RSA’s around the country. They deserve to be made to feel welcome, and have their service celebrated, not compared to others. They do not deserve to be excluded, to the women’s section, called ‘girlie’, or told that they have their grandfather’s medals on the wrong side.

And yet right now, NZDF and Veterans affairs don’t know how many veterans there are out there, which is a disgrace in itself. So when we ask ‘why is it that young veterans don’t join RSA’s? I ask … why would they? About this question, opinions of contemporary veterans range from ‘indifferent’, to ‘angry’ about the RSA.

When I was asked to write this korero, it will be unsurprising to those that know me … I did my homework. I spoke to my friends, dived into some pretty ugly social media posts and ugly comments, & I read up on the history of this issue. I read countless news articles on the subject, and I read your own reports and official documents.

I would like to offer these potential reasons, as insights to the question ‘why do contemporary veterans do not want to join an RSA?’

First, the RSA can feel like it belongs to someone else’s war.
For many younger veterans, the RSA’s public identity is still strongly associated with the great mass mobilisations of earlier generations. As you know, modern service is different: we deployed in much smaller contingents, peacekeeping, specialist roles, repeated deployments, and conflicts that were politically contested or less visible to the public. In RSA’s around the country, you will not see the names of the places we served written on the walls. We do not often see our own service reflected in the stories, imagery and rituals around us.

The club is not always the community they are seeking.
For some, the RSA is associated with a bar, gaming, older members and a traditional club culture. That can be valuable for many people, but it is not the only—or even the primary—thing younger veterans want. Some may want peer support, family-friendly activity, practical assistance, fitness, help with employment, business mentorship, or simply a place where they can be understood. New Zealand media reporting has recognised that the hospitality-focused offer does not automatically appeal to a younger, less drinking-oriented generation.

Younger veterans are busy.
We are building businesses, employing people, building civilian careers, raising children, studying, moving between communities, and managing the demands of transition out of the military. A formal meeting, a committee role, or a membership subscription can feel like another obligation rather than a source of support. For us to make it worth it our time, make worth our while.

Many do not feel ‘veteran enough’.
A person who served for a few years, deployed once, left young, or does not fit the public image of an older veteran may not use the word “veteran” to describe themselves. If the language, membership categories and communications do not make it unmistakably clear that they belong, they will assume the RSA is not for them.

They want practical value before they join.
Younger veterans are likely to ask: What will this organisation do for me, my family, or my mates? They want to see action on transition from the military, employment, advocacy, health, wellbeing and connection with Veterans’ Affairs, ACC and other services. Your own modernisation agenda recognises that career transition and access to support are central to reaching contemporary veterans.

We connect differently.
Younger veterans live in a digital world. They expect to find information online, communicate through social media and messaging, and engage in ways that are flexible and immediate.

Many feel disillusioned by their service.

From the perspective of many who have served recently, the lack of meaningful operational purpose, poor conditions, poor senior leadership and lack of clear strategic direction have left a lot of people pretty fed up. When people leave the military feeling like that, they’re not necessarily looking for another connection to the military. Many want some distance from it, and just to get on with their lives.

Some feel unwelcome, judged or excluded.
This is difficult to say, but it must be said. Research has found that younger, female and culturally diverse veterans reported exclusionary language, cultural rigidity and resistance to modernisation. Many describe the RSA branches as too formal, too old, and difficult for recent leavers to enter. You cannot assume that a younger veteran walking through the door feels immediately welcome.

Some need help but are reluctant to ask.
Pride, stigma and the fear of being seen as a “charity case” remain powerful barriers. Research found that pride stopped many veterans and family members from asking for help, alongside a lack of awareness of what support was available. The RSA must make it easy, private and dignified for a younger veteran to seek assistance. Many will only connect directly, reaching out only through a trusted intermediary.

We have alternatives that feel more relevant.
Organisations such as Te Kiwi Maia, Task Force Kiwi, No Duff Charitable Trust, and SSAANZ  have attracted younger veterans through practical support, family-inclusive events, employment and wellbeing programmes, and peer activity. That is not a criticism of the RSA. It is a lesson. Younger veterans are not disengaged from the veteran community; they choose organisations whose offer matches their lives.

When I left the military, the vast majority of my friends were still in. My social circle revolved around the Army messes, BBQ’s at mates places, or ad hoc gatherings that we made up when the weather was good while we chatted over work emails. When I left all that disappeared. Suddenly the phone calls and emails just stopped. As I flung myself into building my business, and the excitement of starting a fresh new start, after I while I forgot about all those connections I was looking to regain them, so I reached out back to my army mates. They always answered to phone, always wanted to catch up and were genuinely interested in catching up. By it was becoming clear that we had less and less in common. I was lonely and looking to connect with something … anything!

At first attempt at joining the RSA I found myself at the 11am luncheon, surrounded by very friendly and wonderful people, but none that I recognised, and only the employed support staff were within 30 years of my own age. At my second attempt I turned up with my dog, to be told he had to get tied up outside and wasn’t allowed on this section of the beach. At another, I walked in, to a combined clubs, took one look at the drunks at the bar with tomoato sauce spilled in their t shirt and left. I attended a Chunuk Bair dinner, with about 40 people. There were only 3 ex-servicepeople there, everyone else was the wife of a veteran that had passed away, or the son or daughter of a veteran, but had not served themselves. I realised that these were lovely people, but not my people. So I gave up on the RSA.

So what does this mean for you?

It means we must not ask younger veterans to fit into the RSA as it has been. We must ensure the RSA becomes what they need it to be.

We must make it visible that ‘all who served’, belong at the centre of RSA identity. We must offer family-friendly, active, and online ways to connect. We must provide practical welfare, advocacy and support for transition out of NZDF. And we must create genuine leadership pathways for younger veterans—not simply invite them into structures that were designed before they served.

The RSA’s own realignment work has identified the need to promote the organisation to younger veterans, adapt it to be more attractive to them, and make contemporary commemoration more meaningful. It has also recognised that many veterans, particularly those from that post-1995 cohort, remain disconnected.

Now, I recognise that not all RSA’s can be tarred with this brush. There are some great RSA’s doing some amazing work, modernising and getting results. Some RSA’s are creating places where younger veterans feel valued and that they have a contribution to make.

So what is it that contemporary veterans need or want? There are many of us, with many different requirements. I will admit that we are a demanding and picky bunch.

First. Support to veterans. There is a genuine need out there to support people with the cost of living. There are both veterans and current serving people that can’t afford to pay their power bill, or put food on the table. The need is massive, and under-reported as most will sit and suffer in silence until someone they know reaches out to help. The RSA’s role in this area is the same as it has always been. I am not convinced that people are aware of the Defence Hubs, or that there are places that they can go to get assistance, with no strings attached.

Supporting veterans in need, is the first duty of the RSA. That is so important I will say it again. Supporting veterans in need, is the first duty of the RSA.

 

A place to feel welcome. Places were we can have piles of medals, or none at all, and still be treated the same. Places where we will be respected for who we are, ‘veterans’, not what we did, or didn’t do. Respect is not ‘pie’. We will not run out of respect for your service, if you respect ours. We want a place where we can be male, female, or anywhere in between and be treated equally. We want a place where we can bring the people that we love, whoever that may be.

The bickering and the infighting has to stop. The RSA brand has been significantly damaged through events that have been well covered by the media. Members poor behaviour, soured relationships between the different levels of leadership, inappropriate use of poppy donations, and millions of dollars of wasted public donations; may mean that the brand can never recover. These problems need solving, and these internal ructions need to be healed.

Engage with us on the SM channels that we use. Facebook, Instagram, & Tik tok. Put your notifications out there. We are the digital natives, and we navigate the online world effortlessly, at all hours of the day and night. We will not read your .pdf email newsletter no matter how much effort you put into photographs and formatting.  

Gatherings in times and places that suit us. The 11am luncheon is prime work time for us, and we have to go back to work at 1pm. Evenings suit us better, and our weekends can be taken up with work, kids sport, our own sport, or our recreational activities. Make it work for us, not expect us to re-arrange our lives to suit you.

Connections, help and advice in a professional context. You have all run businesses, employed people, been involved in charity, politics, public & private sector organisations, we are just starting out. Your experience and knowledge and connections are of tremendous value to us, but we can’t access it. We value your experience, support and knowledge for the same reason young people have been learning from their elders for countless generations.

Inviting places where we can drop the kids off for a few hours, or a place to bring the kids, where they are welcome, not considered an embuggerance. A place or room with high speed internet to logon for a few hours, with good coffee, a place to meet likeminded people. A place to host an online meeting, use the gym, and have a shower.

Places where we can be physically active. We are out swimming, hunting, fishing, 4Wdriving, running, walking and generally out there being young. I think you’d be surprised how many people would turn up at 8am on a Saturday morning for a walk, run, or even a yoga session. Lord knows some people in this room could also benefit from some hamstring and back stretches!

Finally, places where we can organise, to give of our time and our energy in the service of our community. When it comes to donating time, there are those of us are not looking to ‘get’ something out of the RSA. We don’t need our toenails clipped, or lawns mowed, or houses washed, we can do that ourselves. But we want to see the people that do need those things, get it when they do need it. We are happy to contribute to this, fundraise for RSAs or other groups, or even band together to help out ourselves by giving of our own time, tools, and expertise.

The national modernisation programme is a start. It includes a renewed support and advocacy network, stronger online capability, a new membership and communication system, and a deliberate effort to collect the stories of contemporary veterans. Those are good priorities. But they will only matter if they change the experience of a younger veteran in their local community. The RSA also needs to retake the ground lost in remembrance, support and advocacy. The ground lost to organisations like The Remembrance Army, Te Kiwi Maia, Task Force Kiwi, No Duff Charitable Trust and Mission Homefront.

So what?

Strap yourselves in, this is where it may get emotional.

Jim Collins, in his amazing best selling leadership book ‘Good to Great’ talks about the idea of a bus. In every organisation is it the leader’s responsibility to get the right people on the bus, get the wrong people off the bus, and then get the right people in the right seats.

The question before us is not whether younger veterans care. We do.

The question is whether the RSA is worth belonging to. So, are the right people, in the right seats. To be clear, this is not about getting people off the bus. Not at all. It’s your bus. You long serving members of RSA’s have earned your place on the bus. But perhaps it is time to give up some of the driving, to give up some of those seats at the front, for another group of people. You will always be welcome on board, of course you will, you built the bus. But the future of the RSA depends on making it worthwhile and welcoming to my generation of veterans.

Is the RSA is easy to find? easy to join? easy to belong to? and worth belonging to? If you can answer yes to those questions, you will not need to persuade younger veterans to join. They will join because we see ourselves themselves in the RSA—and because we see the RSA standing beside us, our whānau, and those who come after.

Tēnā tātou katoa.

And with that I will take questions.

Next
Next

NZDF remuneration package risks worsening retention